My rating: 3 of 5 stars
What just happened? Book 2 will either disappoint you because it is book 2 or challenge everything you thought you knew. A Gathering of Shadows felt like a anime filler where the action is happening in the background and filler is being rolled so that at least the viewers will have an idea what their favorite characters are doing when they are not running around saving worlds or fighting monsters. I like Lila Bard, but what is happening with her arc? Like, hello, is Kell even in the picture? Because I can't see him anymore. Rhy, I love you but I don't understand you. I am sorry I don't. And introduction of a new character, Emery Alucard. Interesting character, but the trope is similar to a certain master magician. Royal, yet chained to your obligation and duties. Remind you of someone? Ding. Ding. Kell.
I loved reading the book, every word, but only Holland's story line was the most interesting. There are four London, 3 properly functioning, and one, figuratively a black hole-ish place i.e, a point of no return. Why did 90% of the story took place in one London-Kell's London-Red London? When the other London are still there to be used? And since, we got to know so much about Red London's culture, there Kingdoms, people, distant Kings, magic systems, I would love to know about White London's as well.
And since we are on the same topic, the second book was clearly written like a anime filler, I want to know why wasn't this chance taken to let the readers know more about the fall of black London, through this shadow, who is already present and has started to make new plans for world dominion. But we see no such things.
It would have definitely given the book a certain edge.
Am I the only one who felt there is very high similarity between Element Games fight scenes and Legend of Korra (Fire ferrets-pro bending anyone!)
By the time I finished this, I have more questions.
Lets so hope the last book is able to stamp down some of the burning questions on the tip of my tongue.
View all my reviews








